Home Opinions Letters Letter: Without Jewish education, what Jewish future?

Letter: Without Jewish education, what Jewish future?

Joe Lodge FLICKR

We are parents of a Grade 11 student at the Anne and Max Community Hebrew Academy of Toronto’s Kimel campus (TCK) and of a Grade 7 student at Associated Hebrew Schools of Toronto, who’d been planning to attend TCK in 2018. We are extremely disappointed with the board of TanenbaumCHAT’s response to a recent parent-led proposal to keep the campus open. 

We take issue with the following answers provided by the board:

1. The board expects the Save TCK! parent committee to address the long-term financial stability of the school and to achieve the latter in a reasonable time frame. It took eight years for the board to assemble what it calls an “excellent” administrative team to take the school down. How much time do they feel is reasonable to repair the damage? We barely got three weeks’ notice about the closure, having been notified on March 6.  It is easier to destroy than to rebuild.


2. The Save TCK! committee called for $3-million to be raised from larger donors, in addition to a grassroots fundraising campaign. The board expressed that it was uncomfortable with the conditions attached to this proposal, including the anticipated influence of donors in matters that have normally fallen within the exclusive purview of the school board and administration.

As parents who have been paying either full or partial tuition for so many years (we are in our 11th year, with five more to go), we feel entitled to know where the money goes, especially if we’re prepared to donate thousands of dollars on top of tuition to keep the school open. It seems the board would be happy to take our donations but still want to give the administration carte blanche to the administration to spend that money as they wish. In any scenario, accountability is key to any enterprise, and a school should be no exception.


3. The board claims to have full confidence in the so-called “excellent” administrative team. Based on what? Financial results? Fundraising results? Enrolment results? Our definition of excellence is success. How come the Board has full confidence in those responsible for eight years of failure but cannot give any chance to those interesed in reversing a bad situation?

Our concern is not just for our own children. Our two younger kids will do fine on the TanenbaumCHAT southern campus. We’re concerned for those Jewish families who live further north. As a community, we should feel defeated on behalf of every child that will end up in public school because their family lives too far from TanenbaumCHAT south.

We should feel a sense of failure for every Jewish child who will no longer have access to a Jewish high school education because of poor financial planning – or worse, poor management of available resources. From a selfish perspective, we could happily just take the tuition cut and send our children to the school’s southern campus. As Jews part of a larger community, however, we feel a duty to do whatever it takes to ensure a brighter future for younger generations of Jews. And without a Jewish education, there isn’t much of a Jewish future.

  • Disparishun

    Will we see resignations over this? The entire CHAT board? Part of the CHAT board? Some part of the CHAT administration? Should literally no heads roll, after a surprise announcement with zero warning to the community — what does that say about accountability?

    • Naara

      I’d like to see the entire CHAT board forced out and replaced. They should do the honourable thing and step down and the immediate past president should write a public apology letter for her actions over her tenure. The fundraising team? Turf them all, in my opinion. They had wasteful ideas that led to nowhere except lots of cookies and muffins and girl gossip

  • Aviva Polonsky

    As we speak my heart goes out to all teachers who are are getting notices. Absolutely devastating!

  • Jeff K.

    More importantly – will we see the resignation of Mr. Daniel Held? Or is the board of UJA also complicit in all of this? He will bring the end of Jewish education and the end of our thriving Jewish community!

    • Benben

      You can bet the UJA board knew about this.

  • truthdareisay

    Guess what! The majority of students and adults who are pro Israel in Toronto are NOT the ones who had a Jewish education rather they are Christian Zionists and Jews who had a secular education… Why the heck is that? However It IS crucial that Jewish kids learn about their heritage, their ancestral language, their torah so IF they encounter anti Semitism by their peers, they can quote the Torah, the bible etc. They are the ones who definitely KNOW the Arabs are NOT the original people of the State of Israel..