• News
    • Business
    • Canada
    • Health
    • International
    • Israel
  • Perspectives
    • Ask Ella
    • Ask The Love Rabbi
    • Features
    • Jewish Parenting Wisdom
    • Opinions
    • Ideas
    • Letters
    • Personal Essays
  • Food
  • Culture
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • The Arts
    • Books & Authors
    • Canada 150
    • Jewish Learning
    • June 1967
    • Sports
    • Travel
  • Events
    • Contests
  • Supplements
    • Spotlights
  • Other Communities
    • En Français
    • Russian
  • Subscribe
  • Member Centre
  • Log Out
Search
  • Subscribe
  • Member Centre (eCJN)
  • Log Out
  • Newsletter
  • FaceBook
  • Twitter
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
CJN - Canada’s largest Jewish newspaper
April 21, 2018 - 6 Iyar 5778
CJN - Canada’s largest Jewish newspaper
  • News
    • Miles Nadal donates $11 million to Mount Sinai heart centre

      Federal politicians honour victims of the Holocaust

      Thousands celebrate Yom Ha-Atzmaut in Montreal

      Jews again head the list of groups targeted by hate crimes in Toronto

      Toronto public school responds to anti-Semitic incident

      AllBusinessCanadaHealthInternationalIsrael
  • Perspectives
    • Israel & the Internet: Circa 1948 – April 19, 2018

      Tales from the fascist book club

      The 70 faces Of Israel

      Documenting Israel’s birth

      Liba Augenfeld – the survivor who brought her love of Yiddish with her

      AllAsk EllaAsk The Love RabbiFeaturesJewish Parenting WisdomOpinionsIdeasLettersPersonal Essays
  • Food
    • The Shabbat Table: Happy 70th birthday Israel

      The Shabbat Table: A special post-Passover garlic shlissel challah

      Everyone gets gooey at downtown matzah bake

      Making matzah balls unites a modern Jewish family, says Phyllis Feldman

      The easy way out of Passover

      Bannock and matzah: our breads of affliction

  • Culture
    • Blending Caribbean sun and Jewish history in Curacao

      Novella splendidly blends math and literature

      Segal Centre features more Jewish content in 2018-19 season

      Popular Israeli podcast comes to the stage

      Mollie Jepsen – the Vancouver skier who won gold at the Paralympics

      AllArts & EntertainmentThe ArtsBooks & AuthorsCanada 150Jewish LearningJune 1967SportsTravel
  • Events
    • Chai Lifeline’s Restoring Hope contest (Closed)

      The CJN Prize (CLOSED)

      BRITISH YIDDISH AND KIDDUSH CONTEST (closed)

      The CJN Prize for Young Writers Contest (closed)

      JEWISH MUSIC WEEK 2016 (closed)

      AllContests
  • Supplements
    • Home Beautiful

      CJL Magazine

      Passover Greetings

      Passover Greetings

      MTL Celebrations

      AllSpotlights
  • Other Communities
    • Quel avenir pour les Juifs de France ?

      Israël dans la grande poudrière du Moyen-Orient

      Une entrevue avec Enrico Macias

      L’héritage de Shimon Peres: “Aucun rêve n’est impossible”

      L’intelligence artificielle au service de la robotique

      AllEn FrançaisRussian
  • Subscribe
  • Member Centre
  • Log Out
Home Perspectives Opinions Cloning just feels wrong
  • Perspectives
  • Opinions

Cloning just feels wrong

By
The CJN
-
January 17, 2014
422
0
SHARE
Facebook
Twitter
Jean Gerber

In my book club, we read some books with Jewish themes or authors, as well as others that have no Jewish connection, yet we always end up in discussions relating to community issues, religious tenets or our own lives.

The former category includes The Midwife of Venice, The Dovekeepers, and People of the Book.

The Midwife of Venice gave a glimpse into the way Jews lived in the Venetian ghetto. With Geraldine Brooks’ People of the Book, we looked at my facsimile copy of the Sarajevo Hagaddah with fresh eyes, wondering how in its travels from Spain to Sarajevo it acquired its present characteristics.

We compared Alice Hoffman’s fictional account of the Masada zealots with Yigal Yadin’s account of excavations at Masada. Given Yadin’s conclusions – if you read both books, check his theory about skeletons found near the palace with Hoffman’s fictional reason – you see how she creates a different scenario.

But a real challenge looms with the book I will present this year – an example of one with no direct Jewish connection – Never Let Me Go, by Kazuo Ishiguro, on a timely and delicate subject: human cloning.

From a Jewish perspective, what are we to make of clones being created and used for spare parts by their “models?”

I never thought that cloning humans, even for infertile couples, could be halachically permitted, or ethically, either, for that matter. My thought – even before reading the book – was that cloning an individual is monstrous. We’re all unique: even identical twins, with identical DNA, grow up as different people. There is so much more to us than our DNA: the sum of all our experiences and the way we filter those experiences through perspectives created over a lifetime. So when I went to Rabbi Google for a Jewish perspective, I was shocked.

Here’s some of what I found.

Rabbi Moshe Tendler, in a 1997 New York Times letter to the editor, wrote that in the instance of a Holocaust survivor (for an example) who had no family left, it could be permissible for that person to be cloned so as ensure continuation of a family line. He saw no halachic problem with this, at least in his short letter.

Rabbi Michael J. Broyde agrees (Cloning People and Jewish Law: A Preliminary Analysis). He argues: “I am essentially unaware… of any substantive violation of Jewish law that… occurs when one clones cells from one human being into the egg of another and implants that fertilized egg into a gestational mother… [W]here the clonor is a man such that he fulfils the obligation to be fruitful and multiply… and he cannot fulfil the obligation otherwise… cloning can be classified as a good deed (mitzvah kiyumi); in those circumstance where the clonor is a woman, cloning can be classified as… neither prohibited nor a mitzvah, simply permissible.”

But wait! What about creating clones for spare parts? Or having a second child as a bone marrow or kidney donor for a first child? This rabbi sees no difficulty in the latter, and leaves the former for “ethical” considerations apart from Halachah, quoting the Maharal, who wrote that people were put into this world to participate in creation, to “bring to fruition things that are not found in nature.” Cloning, Rabbi Broyde concludes, “is but one example of that conquest, which when used to advance humanity, is without theological problem in the Jewish tradition.”

I was uncomfortable with this, to say the least. So, onward to Eitan Fiorin’s article “The Case Against Cloning” (Torah u-Madda Journal, 2000).

He argues that in ethical terms, “there are technological heights to which humanity ought not ascend, and I would include human cloning among these.” I guess that would translate as “just because you can do it, doesn’t mean you should.”

The strict halachic view may say yea, but should we not include an ethical imperative in our considerations? Can you say The Boys From Brazil?

There are already signs that a rosy picture of continual human technological advancement is stuttering: what about militaries investigating the possibility of a cloned army, in order to save lives – human lives, that is. And the replacement child? How would you feel about being one?

We have the right to save a life, and we possess the ability to create things not found in nature.

But cloning? It just feels wrong. Let’s see what my book club thinks.

SHARE
Facebook
Twitter
The CJN

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

Miles Nadal donates $11 million to Mount Sinai heart centre

Federal politicians honour victims of the Holocaust

Thousands celebrate Yom Ha-Atzmaut in Montreal

  • Popular
  • Recent
Subscribe to the CJNSubscribe
RSS FeedView
5,518FansLike
856FollowersFollow
10,099FollowersFollow
196SubscribersSubscribe
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe / Member Centre (eCJN)
  • eCJN Archives
  • Supplements
  • Media Kit
  • Advertising Terms
  • Premiums

One on One at Comicon with Leo Leibelman

Purim 2018 on Toronto's streets

Baba Fira's CJN Prize Awards invite

  • News
  • Canada
  • Israel
  • International
  • Opinions
  • The Arts
The award-winning Canadian Jewish News (CJN) is Canada’s largest, weekly Jewish newspaper with an audited circulation of nearly 32,000 and read by more than 100,000 people each week.
© Copyright 2018 Canadian Jewish News
  • Comments Policy
  • Community Links
  • Contact Us
  • Media Kit
  • Privacy Policy
  • Subscribe
  • Admin

Week in Review...

Comes Right to You

Sign up for our Weekly Newsletter

X