• News
    • Business
    • Canada
    • Health
    • International
    • Israel
  • Perspectives
    • Advice
    • Big Ideas
    • CJN Podcast Network
    • Features
    • Opinions
  • Food
  • Culture
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Books & Authors
    • Russian
    • Sports
    • Travel
  • Events
    • Contests
    • Montreal – About Town
    • Toronto – What’s New
  • Supplements
    • Spotlights
  • En Français
  • Podcasts
  • Subscribe
  • Member Centre
  • Log Out
Search
  • Subscribe
  • Member Centre (eCJN)
  • Log Out
  • Newsletter
  • FaceBook
  • Twitter
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
CJN - Canada’s largest Jewish newspaper
January 26, 2021 - 13 Shvat 5781
CJN - Canada’s largest Jewish newspaper
  • News
    • The race to be the leader of the Conservative Party

      Q & A with Ari Greenwald: Responding to a pandemic

      Israel declares complete coronavirus lockdown on eve of Passover

      Gantz says forming a unity government may take more time

      Students learn computer programming RHA FACEBOOK PHOTO

      Online classes up and running in Vancouver

      AllBusinessCanadaHealthInternationalIsrael
  • Perspectives
    • To our readers: Everything has its season. It is time

      Listen: The CJN Podcast Network, Signing Off

      Healthy Aging: Your next doctor appointment will likely be virtual

      Shinewald: Making this awful moment more tolerable

      Marmur: Israel’s Arab citizens lose out in political shift

      AllAdviceBig IdeasCJN Podcast NetworkFeaturesOpinions
  • Food
    • Delicious desserts for Passover

      Festive food for small seders

      Passover meals for the whole day

      Passover taco Tuesday

      Family Seder recipes

  • Culture
    • How philosophy and theology can be in dialogue together

      Socalled is trying to make the best of his downtime

      Veteran singer returns with ‘toxic’ single

      Stories explore relationships between family, friends

      Jewish movies you should stream while self-isolating

      AllArts & EntertainmentBooks & AuthorsRussianSportsTravel
  • Events
    • CJN VIP

      How’d you like to be a VIP? Giveaway

      Giveaway: The Song of Names advance screenings contest (CLOSED)

      CJN-Prize-new-Entry Ad 2019

      The CJN Prize 2019 (Closed)

      Come celebrate the launch of the CJN Podcast Network

      Jewish Music Week Contest (Closed)

      AllContestsMontreal – About TownToronto – What’s New
  • Supplements
    • Passover Greetings

      Focus-on-Ed-2020

      Focus on Education

      Celebrations-MS-20

      Celebrations

      Hanukkah Greetings

      Celebrations

      AllSpotlights
  • En Français
    • À la mémoire d’un ardent ambassadeur de la culture sépharade, Solly Levy Z.’L.’

      “La haine des Juifs n’a jamais eu de limite”

      Le dossier du Dr. Marcus Fraenkel: la réponse de la CIVS

      Israéliens et Palestiniens luttent ensemble contre le coronavirus

      La lutte contre le coronavirus au Centre médical Sheba de Ramat Gan

  • Podcasts
  • Subscribe
  • Member Centre
  • Log Out
Home News Canada Political differences among Jews aren’t new, observers say
  • News
  • Canada

Political differences among Jews aren’t new, observers say

By
Paul Lungen, Staff Reporter
-
October 14, 2015
5155
0
The three main party leaders at the Munk Debate on Foreign Policy

It’s funny. On the national stage, Canada’s relationship with Israel – and which party is best positioned to maintain it – barely became an issue. In interviews with The CJN in our last issue, each of the party leaders proclaimed their support for Israel, for a negotiated peace agreement with the Palestinians and their opposition to the boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) movement. 

Yet on the campaign trail, in a few select ridings where the Jewish vote might make a difference, candidates traded barbs over which party can best be trusted to have Israel’s back. The Conservatives referred to their record of backing the Jewish state when times got tough, and when it wasn’t necessarily a popular position to take. Liberal and New Democratic candidates in Mount Royal, Eglinton-Lawrence, York Centre and Thornhill, among other ridings, argued there is barely any daylight between the parties’ positions on Israel.

Tory candidates pointed to some Liberal candidates’ problematic position on Israel and noted how in the past, the Liberals hadn’t always voted for Israel at the UN. Liberal candidates responded that the Tories ought not make Israel “a wedge issue.”

Other issues have divided Jewish voters, including refugee policy and the whether Muslim women should remove the niqab when taking the oath of citizenship.

At one point in the campaign, a small group of protesters, organized by the Jewish Defence League, gathered outside the Toronto home of Honey and Barry Sherman as they hosted Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau in a fundraiser for the party and for York Centre candidate Michael Levitt. They were protesting what they called the Liberals’ dangerous policy on Iran and the fact a prominent Jewish family would host him.

So is there a wedge developing in the Jewish community based on political orientation? Not according to a handful of observers who believe differences over parties’ positions on Israel and the Mideast won’t have a lasting effect.

The community isn’t monolithic – there’s no one view on which party to support in any election – so political disagreements won’t prevent joint action on a host of other issues, whether it be reacting to events in Israel, tackling poverty or supporting Jewish eduction, they say.

Shimon Fogel was at the centre of some of the political jockeying during the recently concluded campaign. As CEO of the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs (CIJA), he received requests from partisan officials eager for him to endorse their party’s record on Israel. But he declined, citing legal constraints on charitable organizations.

Yet political differences in the community are nothing new. “These different perspectives had emerged long before Honey and Barry Sherman decided to host an event for Michael Levitt and the Liberals,” he said. “It didn’t create cleavages that didn’t exist before.” What’s more, he added, “different perspectives are not inherently a bad thing. The Jewish community benefits from a whole range of different views.” 

As to suggestions Jewish unity might suffer due to politics, “I reject that assertion absolutely,” Fogel said. “CIJA is a big table. We have people representing a wide spectrum of political views. I see nothing but warmth and mutual respect around our table.”

Nelson Wiseman is a professor of political science at the University of Toronto and has tracked voting trends among different Canadian groups. After the last election in 2011, Ipsos queried more than 39,000 voters at exit polls and found “the most striking shift was among Jews to the Conservatives.”

The data looked at a variety of ethnic and religious groups, and found that while the Tories received nearly 40 per cent of the vote overall, a gain from 36 per cent in the prior election, about 52 per cent of Jews backed the Conservatives, up 20 percentage points from 2008. (Jews comprise about one per cent of Canada’s population.) By contrast, only 12 per cent of Muslims voted Conservative, while 46 per cent supported the Liberals and 38 per cent backed the NDP.

Wiseman believes some of the Tories’ Jewish support stems from their strong stand vis-a-vis Israel. In the 2011 election, then-Liberal leader Michael Ignatieff alienated some Jews by suggesting Israel committed a war crime in a bombing in Lebanon. (He had also authored a piece in 2002 calling for an imposed solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, enforced by foreign troops.)

Jews moved to the Conservatives in part over differences on the Middle East, but also because their socio-economic situation improved over the years, Wiseman said. For some, the Tories, who had been seen as the party of the Anglo-Saxon establishment, is now more welcoming for Jews, who are themselves much more established.

Differences over the Middle East were not at play to the same extent in the recent campaign. The Liberal and NDP messages of support for Israel drew Jews back to those parties, though not to the their historical levels, but enough to perhaps swing a vote in ridings held by Tories, he suggested.

Wiseman noted that at the Munk Debate, the issue of Israel was raised by Conservative Leader Stephen Harper, but Trudeau quickly “shut that door,” and the issue wasn’t pursued. For most Canadians, it’s not a factor at all, and for Jewish Canadians, it was less of a factor than in previous elections.

Issie Lyon, chair of the co-ordinating committee of JSpace, a progressive Zionist group, does see a divide in the Jewish community. “Many feel they have to support Harper because of his strong support for Israel, regardless of his domestic policies and everything else he’s done,” Lyon said. “There is a sizable portion of the Jewish community that says we have to take into account what he’s done domestically and others who say it’s not particularly good for Israel because of his blind support.” 

Paul Lungen, Staff Reporter

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

A message to our readers with an update:

À la mémoire d’un ardent ambassadeur de la culture sépharade, Solly Levy Z.’L.’

“La haine des Juifs n’a jamais eu de limite”

Subscribe to the CJNSubscribe
RSS FeedView
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe / Member Centre (eCJN)
  • eCJN Archives
  • Supplements
  • Media Kit
  • Advertising Terms
  • Premiums

75th Anniversary - Liberation of Auschwitz

Ezer Mizion's 2019 Night Shuk

Jeff Golblum conducts O Canada at Fan Expo

  • Canada
  • Israel
  • International
  • Opinions
  • Food
  • Culture
  • En Français
  • CJN Podcast Network
The award-winning Canadian Jewish News (CJN) is Canada’s largest, weekly Jewish newspaper with an audited circulation of nearly 32,000 and read by more than 100,000 people each week.
© 2021 Canadian Jewish News
  • Comments Policy
  • Community Links
  • Contact Us
  • Media Kit
  • Privacy Policy
  • Subscribe
  • Admin