• News
    • Business
    • Canada
    • Health
    • International
    • Israel
  • Perspectives
    • Advice
    • Big Ideas
    • CJN Podcast Network
    • Features
    • Opinions
  • Food
  • Culture
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Books & Authors
    • Russian
    • Sports
    • Travel
  • Events
    • Contests
    • Montreal – About Town
    • Toronto – What’s New
  • Supplements
    • Spotlights
  • En Français
  • Podcasts
  • Subscribe
  • Member Centre
  • Log Out
Search
  • Subscribe
  • Member Centre (eCJN)
  • Log Out
  • Newsletter
  • FaceBook
  • Twitter
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
CJN - Canada’s largest Jewish newspaper
January 23, 2021 - 10 Shvat 5781
CJN - Canada’s largest Jewish newspaper
  • News
    • The race to be the leader of the Conservative Party

      Q & A with Ari Greenwald: Responding to a pandemic

      Israel declares complete coronavirus lockdown on eve of Passover

      Gantz says forming a unity government may take more time

      Students learn computer programming RHA FACEBOOK PHOTO

      Online classes up and running in Vancouver

      AllBusinessCanadaHealthInternationalIsrael
  • Perspectives
    • To our readers: Everything has its season. It is time

      Listen: The CJN Podcast Network, Signing Off

      Healthy Aging: Your next doctor appointment will likely be virtual

      Shinewald: Making this awful moment more tolerable

      Marmur: Israel’s Arab citizens lose out in political shift

      AllAdviceBig IdeasCJN Podcast NetworkFeaturesOpinions
  • Food
    • Delicious desserts for Passover

      Festive food for small seders

      Passover meals for the whole day

      Passover taco Tuesday

      Family Seder recipes

  • Culture
    • How philosophy and theology can be in dialogue together

      Socalled is trying to make the best of his downtime

      Veteran singer returns with ‘toxic’ single

      Stories explore relationships between family, friends

      Jewish movies you should stream while self-isolating

      AllArts & EntertainmentBooks & AuthorsRussianSportsTravel
  • Events
    • CJN VIP

      How’d you like to be a VIP? Giveaway

      Giveaway: The Song of Names advance screenings contest (CLOSED)

      CJN-Prize-new-Entry Ad 2019

      The CJN Prize 2019 (Closed)

      Come celebrate the launch of the CJN Podcast Network

      Jewish Music Week Contest (Closed)

      AllContestsMontreal – About TownToronto – What’s New
  • Supplements
    • Passover Greetings

      Focus-on-Ed-2020

      Focus on Education

      Celebrations-MS-20

      Celebrations

      Hanukkah Greetings

      Celebrations

      AllSpotlights
  • En Français
    • À la mémoire d’un ardent ambassadeur de la culture sépharade, Solly Levy Z.’L.’

      “La haine des Juifs n’a jamais eu de limite”

      Le dossier du Dr. Marcus Fraenkel: la réponse de la CIVS

      Israéliens et Palestiniens luttent ensemble contre le coronavirus

      La lutte contre le coronavirus au Centre médical Sheba de Ramat Gan

  • Podcasts
  • Subscribe
  • Member Centre
  • Log Out
Home Perspectives Opinions The ‘Golden Age’ narrative is bad history
  • Perspectives
  • Opinions

The ‘Golden Age’ narrative is bad history

By
Jimmy Bitton
-
August 18, 2015
4044
0
An Image of a cantor reading the Passover story in Al Andalus, from the 14th-century Haggadah of Barcelona.

In the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, history is arguably the most powerful element. Historical narratives influence the way each side understands the environment in which the conflict occurs, and determine how each side fits day-to-day realities – like flotillas and checkpoints –  into its own collective schema.

One could contend that nothing has contributed more to shaping the political discourse surrounding the conflict than the mythical “Golden Age” narrative. The “Golden Age” refers to the efflorescent period between the mid-seventh century and the mid-13th century when Jews imitated the cultural forms of the great Islamic achievements in philosophy, mathematics, science, medicine, music, astronomy and biblical exegesis. At the time, it is contended, a cultural symbiosis between Jews and Arab-Muslims grew to maturity. 

This narrative was introduced in the 19th century, when German-Jewish historians gave rise to two historiographical constructs: the gloomy narrative of Ashkenazi history – coined the “lachrymose conception of Jewish history” by its opponents – and, the narrative that Jews under Islamic rule lived in a “Golden Age.”

Various Palestinian national movements have appropriated this narrative. Perhaps nowhere is this so clearly referenced than in Article 31 of the Hamas Charter: “Safety and security between Islam, Christianity and Judaism can only prevail under the shadow of Islam and recent and ancient history is the best witness to that effect.” 

In a battle over history, the “Golden Age” narrative serves Hamas in several rhetorical ways. First, the narrative offers a paradigm of an interfaith utopia in which long-sought peace and stability in the Middle East can be achieved. Hamas, meanwhile, presents itself as custodian of the tolerant principles popularly associated to the period. By appropriating the narrative, Hamas presents itself as a seemingly viable solution to the conflict. 

It follows that if the Hamas vision will return the once-lost coexistence, then too, under Hamas rule, will the holy sites of the three great monotheist religions be protected. Adopting the “Golden Age” construct ferments the notion of moral superiority in the conflict. The “Golden Age” moves seamlessly into a collective schema which views Islamic rule as a paradigm of inter-religious harmony between Jews and Muslims.

If this is a true account of the past, then the creation of Israel disrupted an otherwise harmonious reality. Also, if the Jewish experience outside of Israel was safe and secure under Islam, then there was no need for Jewish national independence in a Jewish state. Early Zionism, it can be surmised, revised historical truths in order to advance its criminal political agenda, which has resulted in the usurping of Muslim lands.

Palestinians are therefore the victims in the conflict, and Hamas their natural defenders. In this way, Hamas justifies the use of terrorism against Israel and its citizens as a “natural response” to perceived injustices.

But history reveals that the Jewish experience under Muslim rule was immensely complex and varied over time and place. The “golden age” narrative glosses over inconvenient realities that under Muslim rule, Jews often experienced legal inferiority and violence. The “safety and security” referenced by Hamas was often accompanied by discriminatory legislation and by social, as well as religious, prejudice. Safety and security was dependent on submission to the yoke of Islam. However, even when Jews did submit to Islamic rule, violence was often around the corner. 

The most infamous example of this occurred in the 12th century with the military successes of the Almohad Muslim sect which spread from North Africa into Spain. The Almohads brought great devastation to entire Jewish communities, and many Jews and Christians were forced to convert to Islam or face the sword. 

History records that the portrait of exaggerated harmony is nothing more than bad history. The more this truth is asserted, the less political arsenal groups like Hamas, their supporters and sympathizers, have against Israel. 

Jimmy Bitton is head of the Jewish history department at the Anne & Max Tanenbaum Community Hebrew Academy of Toronto, Kimel Family Education Centre.

  • TAGS
  • Israel-Palestinian conflict
  • Middle East
  • Muslim
  • Palestinian
  • Politics
  • Terrorism
Jimmy Bitton

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

Diamond: Whither the two-state solution?

Horowitz: Choosing sides on Israel

Shinewald: The Canadian thought police

Subscribe to the CJNSubscribe
RSS FeedView
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe / Member Centre (eCJN)
  • eCJN Archives
  • Supplements
  • Media Kit
  • Advertising Terms
  • Premiums

75th Anniversary - Liberation of Auschwitz

Ezer Mizion's 2019 Night Shuk

Jeff Golblum conducts O Canada at Fan Expo

  • Canada
  • Israel
  • International
  • Opinions
  • Food
  • Culture
  • En Français
  • CJN Podcast Network
The award-winning Canadian Jewish News (CJN) is Canada’s largest, weekly Jewish newspaper with an audited circulation of nearly 32,000 and read by more than 100,000 people each week.
© 2021 Canadian Jewish News
  • Comments Policy
  • Community Links
  • Contact Us
  • Media Kit
  • Privacy Policy
  • Subscribe
  • Admin