• News
    • Business
    • Canada
    • Health
    • International
    • Israel
  • Perspectives
    • Advice
    • Big Ideas
    • CJN Podcast Network
    • Features
    • Opinions
  • Food
  • Culture
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Books & Authors
    • Russian
    • Sports
    • Travel
  • Events
    • Contests
    • Montreal – About Town
    • Toronto – What’s New
  • Supplements
    • Spotlights
  • En Français
  • Podcasts
  • Subscribe
  • Member Centre
  • Log Out
Search
  • Subscribe
  • Member Centre (eCJN)
  • Log Out
  • Newsletter
  • FaceBook
  • Twitter
  • Youtube
  • Instagram
CJN - Canada’s largest Jewish newspaper
April 21, 2021 - 9 Iyar 5781
CJN - Canada’s largest Jewish newspaper
  • News
    • The race to be the leader of the Conservative Party

      Q & A with Ari Greenwald: Responding to a pandemic

      Israel declares complete coronavirus lockdown on eve of Passover

      Gantz says forming a unity government may take more time

      Students learn computer programming RHA FACEBOOK PHOTO

      Online classes up and running in Vancouver

      AllBusinessCanadaHealthInternationalIsrael
  • Perspectives
    • A Long-Awaited Return, feat. Jody Avirgan

      To our readers: Everything has its season. It is time

      Listen: The CJN Podcast Network, Signing Off

      Healthy Aging: Your next doctor appointment will likely be virtual

      Shinewald: Making this awful moment more tolerable

      AllAdviceBig IdeasCJN Podcast NetworkFeaturesOpinions
  • Food
    • Delicious desserts for Passover

      Festive food for small seders

      Passover meals for the whole day

      Passover taco Tuesday

      Family Seder recipes

  • Culture
    • How philosophy and theology can be in dialogue together

      Socalled is trying to make the best of his downtime

      Veteran singer returns with ‘toxic’ single

      Stories explore relationships between family, friends

      Jewish movies you should stream while self-isolating

      AllArts & EntertainmentBooks & AuthorsRussianSportsTravel
  • Events
    • CJN VIP

      How’d you like to be a VIP? Giveaway

      Giveaway: The Song of Names advance screenings contest (CLOSED)

      CJN-Prize-new-Entry Ad 2019

      The CJN Prize 2019 (Closed)

      Come celebrate the launch of the CJN Podcast Network

      Jewish Music Week Contest (Closed)

      AllContestsMontreal – About TownToronto – What’s New
  • Supplements
    • Passover Greetings

      Focus-on-Ed-2020

      Focus on Education

      Celebrations-MS-20

      Celebrations

      Hanukkah Greetings

      Celebrations

      AllSpotlights
  • En Français
    • À la mémoire d’un ardent ambassadeur de la culture sépharade, Solly Levy Z.’L.’

      “La haine des Juifs n’a jamais eu de limite”

      Le dossier du Dr. Marcus Fraenkel: la réponse de la CIVS

      Israéliens et Palestiniens luttent ensemble contre le coronavirus

      La lutte contre le coronavirus au Centre médical Sheba de Ramat Gan

  • Podcasts
  • Subscribe
  • Member Centre
  • Log Out
Home Uncategorized Girls, women alienated at Kotel
  • Uncategorized

Girls, women alienated at Kotel

By
thecjnadmin
-
November 6, 2012
1519
1

I was distressed reading the article “Kotel rabbi offers blessings to Canada” (Oct. 25). Rabbi Shmuel Rabinowitz speaks nicely, but his words contain continued al-ienation for a majority of our people. Rabbi Rabinowitz said, “Every Jewish child should have their bar mitzvah at the wall.” In 1981, my family travelled to Israel on a synagogue bar mitzvah trip. I watched from afar as the boys in the group cele-brated their b’nei mitzvah at the Kotel. For the girls, a service was held atop Masa-da. Bat mitzvah at Rabbi Rabinowitz’s Kotel was not, and still is not, an option for every child. 

The Kotel is a special site for me. Unfortunately, on my last trip to Israel, I felt so disconnected from the site. I had no feeling at all. Rabbi Rabinowitz calls the Kotel “the Grand Central Station of the Jewish People.” I grew up in New York. Never in Grand Central Station did I feel I needed to suppress my Jewish identity and practice. I was never made to stand in a separate subway car. In Grand Cen-tral Station, I am not afraid to have my tallit and tfillin.

Rabbi Rabinowitz states that “his responsibilities include ensuring sanctity of the Kotel,” and that “every note [placed in the Wall] is treated as if it were a sefer Torah.” Sanctity includes caring for people at least as much as those notes. Sancti-ty means that all can daven at that wall, for God’s house should be a house of tfil-lah for all people. Fortunately, today there is another option. The Robinson’s Arch section of the Kotel, overseen by the Masorti movement, is open to all to gather, to pray, and to celebrate coming of age as a Jew.

Rabbi Jennifer Gorman

Toronto

*   *   *

Minority monopolizes holy site

 

It was strange for The CJN to print a front-page photo of the smiling chief rabbi of the Kotel, welcoming Canadians to celebrate bar – but not bat – mitzvahs at the Kotel, in the same week that a woman was roughly arrested for reciting the Shema at the Kotel (“Kotel rabbi offers blessings to Canada,” Oct. 25). The rabbi may be happy that he is able to treat the Kotel as an ultra-Orthodox synagogue and pre-vent women from praying aloud, carrying a Torah or even wearing a tallit. But most of us should be outraged that the holiest site in Judaism is monoplized by a small minority and unwelcoming to most Jews. This would be a better topic for a front-page story.

Jeff Denaburg

Toronto

*   *   *

Need to counter Arab propaganda

 

I am afraid that Lawrence Hart’s call in his column for vociferous reaction to the art exhibition, A Child’s View from Gaza, at the Hamilton Public Library is too little, too late (Where is our advocacy?, Nov. 1). The public was already influenced by the exhibit, and objecting to it would be viewed as “muzzling the voice of the poor people of Gaza.” A more effective way is to demand an equal space and equal time to display our exhibition. Such exhibit should be readily available and should follow to counter any Arab propaganda exhibit.

Ami Farkas

Toronto

*   *   *

Torah not susceptible to impurity

 

I want to clarify one point that was made in the article “Course brings Jewish and Muslim women together” (Nov. 1). Nevin Reda commented on the fact that both Judaism and Islam share similarities as far as menstrual laws go. Indeed, there is a strong taboo on sexual relations during menstruation in both traditions.  However, while Islamic law exempts menstruating women from prayer and fast-ing and prohibits them from touching the Qur’an, there is no halachic prohibition against Jewish women praying or reading from the Torah while menstruating. Nonetheless, in some Jewish communities, such customs did persist at certain points in time, and often women did refrain from entering the synagogue during their periods. There is a persistent myth that it is because of women’s “impure” status that they were prevented from reading or touching the Torah, but the Tal-mud is quite clear that the words of the Torah are not susceptible to impurity.

Shari Golberg

Toronto

 *   *   *

Israel can’t afford to ‘bleed a little’

 

I don’t think Henry Kissinger is in a moral position to be giving the State of Israel any advice on when and how to deal with its mortal enemy, Iran (“Iran strike is U.S. call, Kissinger say,” Oct. 11).

When Israel was completely taken by surprise by its Arab neighbours in the 1973 Yom Kippur War, sustained heavy casualties and was in desperate need of American military supplies, the then-secretary-of-state Kissinger advised U.S. president Richard Nixon to wait and “let them [the Israelis] bleed a little first.”

Today, Israel can no more afford to bleed a little than it can allow Iran, a worldwide sponsor of state terrorism and a country that has repeatedly denied the Holocaust and called for Israel’s destruction, to achieve nuclear weapons capability. Nor can Israel totally rely on international sanctions and/or the promises and reassurances of its friends and allies, such as the United States, to prevent that from occurring.

At the end of the day, Israel may very well have to take matters into it’s own hands by taking pre-emptive military action against Iran to ensure it’s own survival and to protect the liberty and security of its citizens.

As Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has succinctly stated in the past, “Israel will always reserve the right to defend itself.”

Ralph Schleichkorn

Montreal

 

 

 

  • TAGS
  • Letters to the Editor
thecjnadmin

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

Letters to the Editor

You flushed it all away Harvey Weinstein

GUEST VOICE: TanenbaumCHAT tuition cut important first step

Subscribe to the CJNSubscribe
RSS FeedView
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Subscribe / Member Centre (eCJN)
  • eCJN Archives
  • Supplements
  • Media Kit
  • Advertising Terms
  • Premiums

OY CANADA: "Oh Canada", Klezmer-Style

PODCAST TRAILER: These Are a Few of My Favourite Jews

75th Anniversary - Liberation of Auschwitz

  • Canada
  • Israel
  • International
  • Opinions
  • Food
  • Culture
  • En Français
  • CJN Podcast Network
The award-winning Canadian Jewish News (CJN) is Canada’s largest, weekly Jewish newspaper with an audited circulation of nearly 32,000 and read by more than 100,000 people each week.
© 2021 Canadian Jewish News
  • Comments Policy
  • Community Links
  • Contact Us
  • Media Kit
  • Privacy Policy
  • Subscribe
  • Admin
 Tweet
 Share
 WhatsApp
 Copy
 E-mail
 Tweet
 Share
 WhatsApp
 Copy
 E-mail
 Tweet
 Share
 LinkedIn
 WhatsApp
 Copy
 E-mail